I agree, unless it is all ihn Desmonds head, like a dream, there would have to be time travel. I guess we will find out next season when we see what Penny has to say to Desmond. If she confirms that he was there, we will know he tjme traveled.

 out of  found this valuable. Do you find this valuable?    

Yep, youve got a good idea there mate and its probably true. Although im no expert on this lost stuff, its probably worth sticking to the series just to see what the hell really is going on.

1  out of 1 found this valuable. Do you find this valuable? Do you?    

first of all the TV series of Lost, WAY TOO FRUSTRATINGLY FRUSTRATING,
Second of all your paranoid theory thinking is just like mine.
During the 50S it wasnt a UFO that crashed in Nevada, Rosswell it was a manmade aircraft specificly designed to carry animals, namely monkeys, out into space. The monkeys were trained to pilot a light spacecraft and the vessel that crashed was a training jet. This was all experiments with NASA and the infamous Area 51 (which today has moved and been split into roughly 14 different sections of location now unkown). Area 51 was testing these chimps and their skill at piloting a live aircraft rather than simulations. The craft actually went haywire and through the ozone layer and stratosphere, the two chimps in their malfunctioning craft came hurtling back down to earth near a village to the south west of Rosswells Area 51. When the crash was cleaned up peices of the craft had melted and bent and morphed and lost parts so untill further examination it was impossible to instantly recognise as human craft. Area 51s agents werent exactly going to own up straight away anyway. Anyway, when the roof was torn off in the crash people saw two small, grey, leathery man shaped things with no eyes and hair in what was presumably the pilot seats. These burnt little things were actually the monkeys whose hair had burnt up and they caught fire upon reentry. it was hard to recognise these little things as chimps so people thought these things fell out the sky+ noone knows what the hell was driving it, they must be ALIENS!!! Makes sense at first but the world went nuts with alien obsession and when scientists discovered that the "aliens" were monkeys and the craft was human the public thought "yeah right" and thats how its started till today. Of course im not saying aliens dont exist, of course theyre real, ive personaly seen UFOs at two different occasions tell me if u dont believe me about that and ill explain it all.
M@

 out of  found this valuable. Do you find this valuable?