"I think this is a very interesting theory. I just started watching LOST this past January of 2007, which means I missed the Lost Experience that came on at the end of the year (2006). I thought the pet cage theory was interesting. I saw someone post a theory that it could be like what happened in the movie Identity, and the person who posted it thought that might be stupid. But I think that would a very good twist in the plot. I think it would be great if in the end the audience found out that all of this really happened in someone's thoughts.

Maybe it is occuring in the mind of Desmond (which was theorized) but maybe Desmond is in the same Schitzo center as Hurliey was (is). So in the end, I think it would be cool if all of this was happening in Desmond's head, in looney bin where not only Hurley, but other people of the Schitzo center are characters in the story, in Desmonds head---Jack, Kate, Sawyer, Jin, etc are all patients in the clinic with Hurley and Desmond, and Desmond has made up the story which is what we've seen on Lost season 1, 2 and now 3."