2 theories:

1. Fertility is a big issue. I always wondered why they kidnapped Sawyer and Kate just to make them break rocks in the yard. I bet it was the intention of the Others to get Sawer and Kate to sleep together. While Claire, Sun, and Rousseau all got pregnant OFF the island - Kate may now be the first to potentially have gotten pregnant ON the island. I wonder where this will lead...

2. Charlie Pace: Jogging the Pace of LOST. An interview with Dom and the producers said that Charlie will have "a great effect on the season finale even without Charlie's physical pressence." Though this is sad, I predict that Charlie will kill himself. However he does this, he will probably do it in a way that has a huge and positive impact on the fate of the survivors. This will serve to simultaneously validate both the notion that Desmond cannot change fate and that he should try. I think that this whole controversy of Charlie's impending death is a wonderful plot device invented to keep the viewers on edge and the suspense can only be met with something as devastating as Charlie dying not by some freak occurance, but by his own conscious act. This would also serve to address and maybe even seemingly reconciile Hume's philosophy of "Free-will vs. Determinism".

On a related note, I recommend checking out David Hume on wikipedia, with brief paragraphs on his philosophies on tings like "Causation," "Practical Reason: Instrumentalism & Nihilism," "Sentiment Based Ethical Theory," "Free WIll vs. Determinism," "The Is-Ought (as in what IS and what SHOULD BE) Problem," "The Problem of Miracles," and "The Design Argument" it is not hard to make the connections between Hume and his Lostaway counterpart Desmond.

Please respond, I really enjoy other's takes on my ideas.

1 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you find this valuable? Do you?

Keyword tags:

Post reply

Show Last Reply

nsoltysiak

wowww

Apr 19 2007, 10:32 AM EDT by Anonymous

Anonymous

Confirmation for D.O.C.

Apr 17 2007, 11:27 PM EDT by Anonymous

Anonymous

Who is Anthony?

Apr 12 2007, 7:03 AM EDT by Anonymous

nihilus

DEATH OF SAYID?

Apr 8 2007, 7:29 AM EDT by nihilus

Thread started: Mar 13 2007, 4:41 PM EDT Watch

Is Sayid going to die? This confrontation with the cat reminds me a bid of the past episodes in which both Mr Eko and Shannon died in that way. Both of them where haunted by Jemi and Walt before they where killed "by the island"!!!

2 out of 3 found this valuable. Do you find this valuable? Do you?

Keyword tags:

Post reply

Show Last Reply

Last Reply:
RE: DEATH OF SAYID?
By: nihilusApr 8 2007, 7:29 AM EDT

"Sorry, what I meant to add to that statement was this:

The smokemonster took the form of the cat, like it did with Jemi and Walt, leading to Eko and Shannons death. Jack's dad and Hurley's friend are good arguments against this though. But when Eko looks into the smokemonster he sees flashes of people from his past, so I think the smokemonster does have the ability to read people's pasts and use them against them to push them to their wits end, where it may or may not kill them. This cat could be the first sign of this process happening to Sayid, seeing as Locke seems to be regressing, Sayid poses the most threat to the others. I mean hell, remember how the others are supposed to be such great fighters? Except for Ethan, who only got beaten when he was ganged up on by like 8 survivors, Sayid was able to single handedly kick Mikhail Bukanin's ass, which makes him the only one in Lost history to have beaten an Other in one on one, hand to hand combat.

I think the black horse Kate saw is an exception. I think it is explained by ranch-style Flame station, it is probably a real horse that escaped. Remember how Sawyer saw it too? But then again Sayid saw Walt too, which brings us back to Sayid...

In the descriptions of the upcoming episodes we are made to understand that Kate is off with Juliet. Locke is off with Ben. And I think Rousseau might be off looking for Alex. So where is Sayid? I wouldn't be surprised if the producers thought it was time to kill of someone else big and widely appreciated by fans, and they might be throwing us all this Charlie crazyness to make us unprepared for who it will ACTUALLY be...Sayid?

I sure hope not."

That's exactly what I ment.Besides they have showed us nothing about that horse and Cates past and Hurley wasn't lets say a bad guy during the past.I begin to believe that this monster kills bad peolpe

Do you find this valuable?

Anonymous

Don't kill Sayid!!!

Apr 3 2007, 5:24 PM EDT by Anonymous

Thread started: Mar 20 2007, 9:43 PM EDT Watch

This message is a two parter, it's long, so don't read it if you don't care that much about Sayid or the smokemonster. But I think it contains some good insights:

Look at all the episode descriptions of the upcoming episodes, everyone in the party of Locke/Sayid/Kate/Rousseau is mentioned except for Sayid. And Locke is said to be on a "destructive rampage" that began with the "accidental" killing of Mikhail Bukanin....

I'm a believer that the smoke monster takes the form of past relations (IE Jemi, Walt, etc.) in order to get into the heads of their next victims. The smokemonster took the form of the cat, like it did with Jemi and Walt, which lead to Eko and Shannons death. Jack's dad and Hurley's friend are good arguments against this though, but both instances did make Hurley and Jack severely question themselves.

Anyway, when Eko looks into the smokemonster he sees flashes of people from his past, so I think the smokemonster does have the ability to read people's pasts and use them against them to push them to their wits end, where it may or may not kill them. I also think the smoke monster goes after the strongest and most capable survivors. This cat could be the first sign of this process happening to Sayid, seeing as Locke seems to be regressing, Sayid poses the greatest threat to the others. I mean hell, remember how the others are supposed to be such great fighters? Besides the fight with Ethan, who only got beaten when he was ganged up on by like 8 survivors, Sayid was able to single handedly kick Mikhail Bukanin's ass, which makes him the second one in Lost history (after Ana-Lucia) to have beaten an Other in one on one, hand to hand combat.

6 out of 6 found this valuable. Do you find this valuable? Do you?

Keyword tags:

Post reply

Show Last Reply

Anonymous

Locke - singlehandedly ruining all chance of rescue

Apr 2 2007, 1:06 PM EDT by Anonymous

Thread started: Apr 1 2007, 10:08 PM EDT Watch

You know, I love Locke as much as the next guy, but come to think of it - has Locke ever done anything that helps the survivors get off the island? In the first season he bashes Sayid on the head right when he was getting a signal on the airplane transmitter, in the second season he destroys the hatch, in the third season he destroys the flame station (along with its satallite) and then he destroys the sub...that's a pretty terrible track record. He has in fact sabotaged every logical attempt they've ever made to be saved, or at least the ones that involved technology. I find it really interesting because he seems to be the character that represents faith and salvation. So it sort of coincides. But it could also be seen as incredibly selfish and destructive. What kind of commentary is Lost making on spirituality here?

Do you find this valuable?

Keyword tags:

Post reply

Show Last Reply

Anonymous

How good of a fan are you?

Apr 2 2007, 12:29 AM EDT by Anonymous

Anonymous

Jacob's list

Mar 24 2007, 4:21 PM EDT by Anonymous

Anonymous

brainwashing

Mar 24 2007, 12:25 PM EDT by Anonymous

Anonymous

NIKKI FLASHBACK!

Mar 22 2007, 3:50 PM EDT by Anonymous

1 2 | Next

Subject:
Message:
Quote:
Keyword tags:

Lost News	Lost News Archive: 6/30/08-7/27/08	Episode Guide: Season One
Episode Guide: Season Two	Lost: Behind the Scenes	hey
Episode Guides	What is it?	Season Three Predictions
Season Three DVD	You Write It	Season Premiere Date Announced!

Location: Episode Guide: Season Three

Threads

Start a New Thread as Reply as Anonymous (Get credit for your thread)

Related Content