The Debate Is On - History Page

	Date/Time	Made By	Edit Note	Type	Scope
	Jun 8 2008, 6:02 PM EDT	MadTija	Changed some capital letters here and there.	edit	22 words added 23 words deleted
Change: i thinkIthink that they are free from the island but are stuck in some current and will eventually turn around again without knowing it.So i View changes from previous version. (Word count: 2198)
	Apr 6 2008, 10:33 AM EDT	lulamae	added end of Michael/Walt debate	edit	41 words added
Change: " for more information. In short, yes, Walt and Michael did get off the island, however, metaphorically, Michael was never "free" from it. Ben told them that they could go home, he has no reason to keep them- they went home.Ben told them that they View changes from previous version. (Word count: 2198)
	Apr 2 2008, 5:33 PM EDT	savvysuzy	Discussed Des's psychic abilities	edit	36 words added
Change: Desmond doesn't seem to be wanting to offer up any of his psychic abilities to inform anyone else of anything -- after what happened to Charlie. Plus, he must have some insights, but "mums" the word. What if the "discharge" caused the protective View changes from previous version. (Word count: 2159)
	Oct 16 2007, 6:30 PM EDT	wetpaint		edit	11 words deleted
Change: it makes more sense that everyone is on the same island. Polar Bears are strong swimmers and could have made the mile-ish distance to the island easily. _____________________________________________________________________This is the official Lost wiki of ABC's Lost TV show View changes from previous version. (Word count: 2123)
	Sep 23 2007, 12:20 AM EDT	Alvar_Hanso	Updated and Deleted Old Debates into New Topics	edit	79 words added 603 words deleted
Change: The recent(12/06/06) Official Lost Podcast with writers Damon Lindelof and Carlton Cuse confirmed that the others do have a seperate "Alcatraz" island which they are View changes from previous version. (Word count: 2135)
	May 25 2007, 12:50 AM EDT	makros76	Walt and Michael not free	edit	169 words added
Change: MAKROS---When Ben let Walt and Michael go with the boat, he seemed honest enough when he gave them the compass bearing (which would take them View changes from previous version. (Word count: 2675)
	May 7 2007, 5:20 AM EDT	Anonymous	Sarcasam joke	edit	19 words added
Change: No way Ben told them they'd get off the island and Ben always tells the truth (now that's sarcasam.) Debate: Juliet is actually working with Ben and it's all part of a plan to break Jack. Yes, Juliet is lying and she and Ben are on the same side No, View changes from previous version. (Word count: 2498)
	May 6 2007, 5:13 PM EDT	Anonymous	NOPE	edit	38 words added 10 words deleted
Change: place to go!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Michael and Walt are going to be back on the island.island at the end of season 3!! If the young actor playing Walt was growing up too fast, they could just View changes from previous version. (Word count: 2477)
	Apr 28 2007, 9:00 PM EDT	Anonymous		edit	14 words added
Change: There is no way off the island. Anyway, a motorboat won't take you far.No way. Ben's dishonest and too interested in Walt to have let them sail into the sunset.Ben told them that they could go home, and he also said the main island is home. (Home View changes from previous version. (Word count: 2449)
	Apr 26 2007, 5:53 PM EDT	Anonymous		edit	35 words added
Change: Also, if the island is associated with unique magnetism, surely any compass on the boat (wasn't it a compass bearing that Ben gave to Michael) wouldn't work. This could also explain why Desmond couldn't leave. Debate: Juliet is actually working with Ben View changes from previous version. (Word count: 2434)
	Apr 11 2007, 4:34 PM EDT	Anonymous		edit	45 words added
Change: Does anyone rember that a few episodes ago Ben told John that the only way off the island was by the submarine? And Michael and Walt weren't on a submarine where they? So they're not going to be able to go back to THEIR home! They are unlikely View changes from previous version. (Word count: 2396)
	Apr 1 2007, 10:44 PM EDT	Anonymous	updated. if u r goin to start a pg stay with it!	edit	231 words added 18 words deleted
Change: Maybe there are only cameras in certain houses/buildings. When Juliet made the tape she didn't say anything or make any noises- she just held the View changes from previous version. (Word count: 2349)
	Mar 26 2007, 8:32 AM EDT	mysteriousisland		edit	20 words added
Change: Maybe he's not dead, just unconscious. He passed through the sonic fence very quickly. So Maybe, we'll see him again. HE IS DEAD, thanks Locke?! Debate: Despite what Ben says, The Others really are on the same island as the survivors of Oceanic Flight 815. Yes, Ben's a View changes from previous version. (Word count: 2133)
	Mar 16 2007, 9:51 PM EDT	Anonymous		edit	5 words added
Change: HE IS DEAD, thanks Locke?! Debate: Despite what Ben says, The Others really are on the same island as the survivors of Oceanic Flight 815. Yes, Ben's a liar and The Others are on the same island as everyone else.Home for The Others is View changes from previous version. (Word count: 2111)
	Mar 1 2007, 5:29 AM EST	MarcusTee	Theory on the "Third Island"	edit	129 words added 3 words deleted 2 images added
Change: Home for The Others is due North of where the Survivors crashed according to the map Sayid is looking at in "Glass Ballerina" and according View changes from previous version. (Word count: 2106)
	Mar 1 2007, 5:13 AM EST	MarcusTee	Added info on location of island.	edit	50 words added
Change: Home for The Others is due South of where the Survivors crashed according to the map Sayid is looking at in "Glass Ballerina" and according to the scene just before the openning credits in that same episode. Not on a third Island but just over the mountains to the South. View changes from previous version. (Word count: 1978)
	Feb 28 2007, 11:34 PM EST	Anonymous	Home does not equal the old life before the plane went down.	edit	56 words added
Change: and he also said the other (third) island is home. Home is where the Sheriff lives and where the book club meeting was being held when the plane when down. yes. walt's stepfather gave him back to michael because he View changes from previous version. (Word count: 1928)
	Feb 6 2007, 7:25 PM EST	Anonymous	I don't know if my reasoning is accurate but, I am a huge fan	edit	50 words added
Change: i think that they are free from the island but are stuck in some current and will eventually turn around again without knowing it.So i think they aren't written off the show just yet. Also, where would they go if they don't know where they are in the first place? View changes from previous version. (Word count: 1872)
	Feb 1 2007, 7:17 AM EST	lulamae	removed misplaced opinion	edit	15 words deleted
Change: I stopped believing the "snow globe theory" after recalling the food drop the survivors found.Have you noticed that there are things that don't make sense in the show? (Besides the show itself, I mean.) Here are some controversial questions that have the web buzzing. Buzz in your own answers. View changes from previous version. (Word count: 1819)
	Jan 31 2007, 11:21 PM EST	Anonymous		edit	15 words added
Change: I stopped believing the "snow globe theory" after recalling the food drop the survivors found.Have you noticed that there are things that don't make sense in the show? (Besides the show itself, I mean.) Here are some controversial questions that have the web buzzing. Buzz in your own answers. View changes from previous version. (Word count: 1834)