Already a member?
Sign in
Location: Is it Desmond's Fault that Charlie's dead?
Discussion: No!
Keyword tags:
None
Watch
 kreas |
No!
Sep 1 2007, 12:10 PM EDT You guys all have it wrong dont you get that charlies bad luck was from the ring his brother gave him. once charlie took it off his bad luck went away. But desmond did not know that was the problem. He wanted charlie to dye so he could stop having the visions of charlie dying. 0 out of 4 found this valuable. Do you? |
 Emerica01 |
RE: No!
May 25 2008, 5:47 PM EDT "You guys all have it wrong dont you get that charlies bad luck was from the ring his brother gave him. once charlie took it off his bad luck went away. But desmond did not know that was the problem. He wanted charlie to dye so he could stop having the visions of charlie dying. "Hmmm, i never thought of it that way i would have to say i agree with the ring part. makes perfect sence. and as soon as Liam gave Charlie the ring, he started to turn into a man(supporting his family/get off the drugs/ etc) But Desmond did not want him to die. he tried to go down, but Charlie knocked him out with the ore. And also. it didnt actually show desmonds last vision, so he may have been lying about some of it. or all of it. Who knows. i think he was lying about it all personallyl. Because he said he saw claire get on the chopper and get rescued with Aaron. Witch is not happening. Claire went nuts or whatever happened to her. and Aaron is back in the states with Jack and Kate. Do you find this valuable? |
